Europa – Vergleich mit einem führungslosen Schiff, das schon von „Piraten“ übernommen wurde (Bild: KI)

Ein Beitrag von Alfonso Quijano

Europe today resembles a leaderless ship drifting on the world’s oceans, a haunting image drawn from Herman Melville’s Benito Cereno. In this mythopoetic lens, the continent is personified by the figure of the aging, spiritually depleted Spanish nobleman Don Benito, who, despite his ancient lineage and ties to tradition, is unable to perceive or resist his own decline. Facing him is the pragmatic American captain Amasa Delano, a figure of technical-economic „common sense“ who cannot even apperceive the depth of the European crisis because his worldview is grounded in a purely functional, soulless „enterprise“. This existential paralysis defines the „European Hamlet,“ a continent caught in the confessional and political fragmentation of its heritage, standing indecisively between fronts and suffering from a profound lack of identity regarding substantial questions of truth. The post-war consensus, which sought to build a myth-free administrative zone for atomistic consumers through economic miracles and technocratic integration, has reached its limit; in the face of dwindling economic success and increasing international isolation, the „Union“ is revealed as a perplexed construct, unable to offer the cultural or political binding forces necessary for survival, certianly if no imminent (perceived) enemy stands infront of his door. After 1945, the European movement centered around Anglo-American-oriented figures such as Churchill and Adenauer, setting into motion forms of integration—like the Coal and Steel Community—that were driven by transatlantic elite groups such as the Round Table Movement and the Rhodes-Milner Circle. While these projects initially provided a framework for recovery, they ultimately created an ideal vacuum that has become palpably noticeable in the wake of the war in Ukraine. The time has grown ripe for a ruthless and absolute self-assertion, a decision for sacrifice and a return to a genuine, responsible conception of power to prevent the dark game of chance from unleashing total chaos. To navigate this crisis, we must look to a genuinely European thinker—Carl Schmitt—who theorized the decline of the Ius publicum Europaeum and the middle position of Germany with unsurpassed sharpness. Salvation is only possible if Europe reflects at the last moment and finds its way back to a living order resting on the will for what is right and good.

The urgency of this decision is catalyzed by a radical shift in the global geopolitical „vibe.“ The United States, formerly the guarantor of the liberal-universalist order, has signaled a pivot toward a cold, transactional foreign policy strategy. According to the National Security Strategy of 2025, the US now seeks an opportunity-based extraction of European nation-states from the EU, preferring bilateral deals with sovereign, nationally-oriented forces to prevent the emergence of an autarkic European „Greater Space“ (Großraum). While the EU elite clings to a universalist „over-fulfillment morality“ and a „tyranny of values“ that often serves as a tool for morally condemning political opponents as „sub-human“ and despisable public enemy, the US and other rising powers have moved into a „violent interregnum“. This interregnum is marked by the rise of a radical technosphere—most prominently in China—that fuses state-capitalist dirigisme with robotic social engineering and a military-industrial complex driven by AI and biotechnology. This technocratic logic relentlessly strives for a global „machine of machines“, a planetary synchronization that reduces the human being to a prosthetic link in a soulless apparatus. In Christian eschatology, this global centralization under technocratic-industrial rule is the sign of the Antichrist, a „Babylonian project“ of human self-encapsulation that seeks to burst through the created order with technological „intelligence“. Resistance to this requires Europe to defend the plurality of political units and reclaim its metaphysical mission as a Katechon—the restraining historical power that delays the process of global centralization. A true European identity must define itself in political-theological, historical, and geographical categories rather than abstract universalism, euro-faschism or be hindered by an anachronistic and solipsistic nationalist chauvinism.

The Constitutional Theory of the Federation: Beyond the Dilatory Compromise

To resist this planetary „neutralization“, Europe must move beyond the „dilatory compromise formula“ (dilatorischer Formelkompromiss) of its current structure and actualize itself as a true Federation (Bund). A Federation is not a centralized superstate nor a mere administrative alliance; it is a political unity based on „substantial homogeneity“—an existential kinship and conformity of its member states. This homogeneity is not to be found in the abstract, liberal-universalist declarations of „European values“ in Article 2 TEU, which de facto decompose national peculiarities; rather, it is a deep similarity of political forms of existence that existentially excludes the possibility of enmity between members. The defining characteristic of the Federation is the „abeyance of sovereignty“ (Schwebezustand), a productive suspense where sovereignty is located neither exclusively with the whole nor the parts, but is held at a distance by the sufficiency of the common political substance. This state of suspense allows for a „unity in plurality“, where the Federation remains a permanent association of independent units, provided that the will of the Federation is perceived by the member states as their own organic self-determination. Historically, this was achieved in the Bismarckian Empire through a complex system of „double reinsurance“ — the solidarity of princes and the national will —which functioned as long as a representative leader could balance these forces and preserve the „federal basis“. However, Schmitt viewed the development of such hegemonic federations with skepticism if they relied on „dilatory formal compromises“ that merely concealed contradictions through ambiguous language, political unconciousness and the deferral of political decisions. In a political form that is „total out of weakness“, political unity becomes a mere byproduct of daily compromises between heterogeneous power groups, leading to resistance-less political servitude.

The most glaring deficiency of the contemporary EU is its lack of a true federal ius belli—the independent right to decide on the existential enemy. While the „mutual assistance clause“ of Article 42(7) TEU obligates states to provide aid in the event of an attack, it remains a nationally interpretable and intergovernmental arrangement that lacks a sovereign, representative carrier of the decision (in the foreign-political state of exception). In a true Federation, the decision on the „state of emergency“ does not merely react to a factual incursion but identifies a metaphysical enemy that diametrically negates the Federation’s collective mode of being. Article 42(7) TEU, by contrast, is triggered automatically and remains „NATO-compatible“, lacking the preventive and definitional federal sovereignty required for true political existence. The current fragmentation within the EU regarding the Ukraine conflict — demonstrated by the divergent stances of Austria, Hungary, and Slovakia etc. — reflects a blatant deficit in substantial homogeneity. Germany, as the economic engine, has often found itself caught in an „internal disunity“ marginally evading hegemony while its leadership occasionally emphasized a role for peace, highlighting that without a „firm resolve“ against existential threats, the Federation remains a „provisional system“ vulnerable to „indirect powers“. Contrary to this lack of homogeneity, Eurocrats are aggressively forcing integration toward a centralist superstate, an agenda that risks consuming the very diversity and substantive European heritage the Federation is meant to preserve.

The Metaphysics of Representation: »Making« the Invisible Visible

The bridge across this earthquake zone of disintegration is the principle of representation. For Schmitt, representation is not a social-technical procedure of counting votes, but the „letting be visible of an invisible idea“ through a ontologically conscious and noble person. A political entity cannot exist in absolute naturally present homogeneity; it requires a dignified representative to highlight a metaphysical or theological principle — a „higher being“ — from the sphere of invisibility into public visibility. True representation presupposes a personal dignity and authority that cannot be derived from the mere will of voters, personal charisma or the power of concealed financiers but rests on a higher ideal substrate. This representative power must be an expression of the „triply great form“: the aesthetic form of the artistic, the juridical form of the law, and the world-historical form of power. In the federal context, the object of representation is the idea or principle that forms the basis of homogeneity, such as the historical genealogy and theological mission of the Reich or the Universitas Christiana. Representation actualizes this transcendent principle in a world of immanence and technocratic this-worldly activism. It serves as a reconciliation between the plural units of the member states and the singular unity of the Federation. This principle must be historically grown, derived from  theological truth and not be an artificial imposition; rather, it is born within the lived mentality and political-historical and theological actuality of Europeans.

The subject of representation in a Federation is also for Schmitt typically a more collegial body, such as a federal assembly, which must protect the collective mode of being against vital threats. This can be understood through the concept of repraesentatio identitatis, rooted in the conciliarist tradition of the Church. In this scheme, a qualified part acts in forma universitatis, becoming factually identical with the whole for the execution of certain acts. This „mystical person“ (persona mystica) represents the legal and ideal unity of the association, transforming the unorganized crowd into an acting entity. This is not a static state, but a dynamic act of self-preservation that must hold the tension between the identity of the peoples and the represented unity of the whole. Identity and representation are dialectically intertwined; identity is the lived, natural agreement of a people with itself, while representation gives that identity full political realization and visibility. Without a representative depiction in the real world, an association’s identity is not even thinkable. Therefore, the European Federation must be more than a technical committee; it must be a representative organ that guards the „res publica“ and makes it effective and obvious to all.

The Sword of the Federation: Ius Belli and the Deficit of Decision

The transition from the metaphysical principle of representation to the concrete political reality of a Federation finds its most acute expression in the question of the ius belli—the right to war. In Carl Schmitt’s theory, a genuine Federation is defined by a sectional distribution of this right: while member states renounce war among themselves to ensure a permanent internal pacification, the Federation as a whole must possess the sovereign capacity for external self-preservation against common enemies. This is not a mere technicality of international law but the ultimate criterion of political existence. A Federation that cannot identify its enemy or resolve to defend its „existential agreement“ remains a „provisional system“ at the mercy of external powers. When we examine the contemporary European Union through this lens, the structural deficiencies become glaringly apparent. The current Common Security and Defence Policy (CSDP) and the much-cited assistance clause of Article 42(7) TEU are essentially intergovernmental arrangements that preserve national sovereignty at the expense of federal decision-making. Unlike a true federal right to war, which would allow a representative carrier—be it a collegial assembly or an executive head—to sovereignly constitute a state of emergency, the EU’s mechanisms are reactive and nationally interpretable. Article 42(7) triggers aid only after an armed attack has occurred and places this aid under the final authority of the UN Security Council, thereby stripping the European project of its preventive and definitional sovereignty. This „automatic“ obligation lacks the „firm resolve“ of a representative who can distinguish between a factual incursion and a „metaphysical enemy“ that negates the Federation’s collective mode of being.

The current fragmentation of the European response to the conflict in Ukraine shows itself as a pathognomonic moment, revealing a profound lack of substantial homogeneity—the existential kinship required for a Federation to act as a unit. When member states like Hungary under Viktor Orbán or Slovakia under Robert Fico prioritize energy security and peace negotiations over military escalation, while others push for a total war-policy, the „federal spirit“ dissolves into a series of colliding national interests.  By no means does this intend to relativize the vital interests of energy policy oft the named states. However, in the ideal framework of a European federation these valid national interests should be mediated with the European unity oft he collective. The erosion of unanimity proves that the best will is powerless against the concrete reality of differently natured peoples when a common concept of the enemy is absent. Germany’s own hesitation — exemplified by Chancellor Scholz’s maneuvering between transatlantic pressures and a domestic self-portrayal as a mid-way peace-remainer — further highlights the internal disunity of the EU engine. In the absence of a shared existential resolve, the „Eurocrats“ in Brussels attempt to force integration through a centralist superstate model, an activist war-policy sovereignty that threatens to consume the diversity and common existence in a quite literal sense (!) of the member states rather than representing it. For Schmitt, this technocratic unitarization is the opposite of a true Federation; it is an attempt to replace the „visibility of power“ and personal responsibility with an anonymous machine, leading inevitably to a resistance-less political servitude to indirect powers that actually dictate the line between enemy and friend thereby intentionally expedite centralist unitarisation.

The Hegemon and the Guarantee: Lessons from the Bismarckian Reich

A sustainable Federation requires more than just military coordination; it necessitates a constitutional „guarantee of existence“ that secures the continued political life of its members within a „unity in plurality“. This guarantee is not a mere legal promise but a fundamental law of political life that legitimizes the state-like character of the parts within the whole. Historically, the Bismarckian Empire of 1871 provides a complex case study of how a hegemon power—Prussia—could serve as the representative concretization of federal unity. Through a system of „double reinsurance“ Bismarck balanced the dynastic solidarity of the federal princes with the national-democratic will of the people, ensuring that the smaller states felt secure because the Prussian leadership guaranteed the unity they required for survival. However, Schmitt viewed this „federal state“ (Bundesstaat) with great skepticism, characterizing it as a „bourgeois-legitimist-dynastic compromise“ that used the term „federation“ as a „veil“ to cover unresolved contradictions between monarchical and democratic principles. This „state of suspense“ was a „dilatory formal compromise“ that functioned only as long as a strong representative head — Bismarck — could maintain the equilibrium. Once that personal responsibility vanished, the system regressed into a „party federal state“ where political substance migrated to „indirect powers“ and interest-driven factions, ultimately rendering the state defenseless against its enemies. In ordert to avoid the fatal dependence on a single great, but always flawed man, a collective search towards a deeper theological grounding of federational unity must be initiated, in order to avoid the dawning of a superficial caesarism as Spengler depicted it for the civilizational phase oft he occident, also revealingly translatable as evening-land (Abendland), the land of the sinking sun.

The contemporary European project faces a similar aporia as the „Bismarckian Reich“: it fluctuates between a sham compromise of technocratic management and a latent drive toward a national-democratic centralism that would abolish the sovereign suspense essential to a Federation. Schmitt warns that as soon as a uniform „state people“ replaces the federal (also contractual) ground with a national constitutional decision — as happened in the USA after the Civil War — the Federation as a permanent association of distinct units is lost. To avoid this fate, Europe must rediscover the role of the hegemon not as a foreign-determining power, but as a „representative leadership“ grounded in a „lived trust“ and a shared cultural and religious horizon. Such a leadership, which one might envision for a self-positioned and finally complex-free Germany in Central Europe, would act as a „federal counter-power“ against the planetary synchronization of the technocratic world. This requires a move away from the „process-progress“ of EU-integration — which revealingly the German protestant jurist and constitutional historian Rudolf Smend once conceived as a content-arbitrary „community experience“ — toward a robust doctrine of representation that can stand firm during the „state of emergency“. While integration is the maintenance of the bolts and pillars of a bridge, representation is the static construction itself that must prove its unity when the earthquake of history strikes.

Conciliarism and the Mystical Person: Toward a Political Triadology

The ultimate actualization of the European Federation lies in the concept of repraesentatio identitatis—a corporate self-articulation deeply rooted in the conciliarist and corporation-theoretical traditions of the Middle Ages. In this framework, the Federation is represented not as a technical committee of interests, but as a „mystical person“ (persona mystica) where a qualified part acts in forma universitatis, becoming factually identical with the whole for the execution of political will. Through a necessary legal fiction (fictio iuris), the action of a federal organ is elevated to the expression of the entire persona mystica, thereby uniting the unorganized multitude of peoples into a political community of political existence. This is the „theological-sacramental“ core of federal representation: it is the personification or actualization of an invisible idea or person — such as the Universitas Christiana or the historical genealogy of the Reich — through the person of the representative. Analogous to how the Church makes present the Christ who became godman, a representative federal assembly must highlight the transcendent principle of European unity from the sphere of invisibility into public visibility. This „Political Triadology“ is the only sufficient answer to „Hamlet’s hesitation“, for it provides a spiritual authority that enables agency through a shared identity. It rejects the mathematical body of pure counting and technocratic registration in favor of a spiritual authority that manifests the consensus of all parts.

Europe stands today between „technocratic extinction“ and a „theologically grounded rebirth“. The current myth-free administrative zone offers no protection against the „predator teeth“ of global powers or the „machina machinarum“ that seeks to reduce the human being to a prosthetic link in a global technosphere. Resistance requires a truth-oriented return to a (non-supranational!) religious and national identity, understanding power as a gift from God that must be bound by a sacred continuity and a Christian virtue ethics. Representation in this sense is like the light of a prism: the invisible white light of the metaphysical idea of unity is refracted through the representative body, becoming visible in the „color multiplicity“ of the member states without losing its original unity. This reorientation cannot be externally imposed; it must be a synergetic movement initiated from within the peoples, where representative elites mediate between an organic, faith-based national identity and their federal responsibility conquering a new foreign-political position of Europe within an ethnopluralist Great-Space-Order which rises on the geopolitical horizon, whether one desires it or not. Either the European Federation will embrace its role as a restraining force rooted primarily not in economic or military power but cultural and religious tradition setting our continent truly unique; either a newly born European Federation will find and accept its role as European Katechon — the restraining power against the technocratic Antichrist — or it will be offered as a sacrificium to a hyper-technologized world. The decision for the will for what is right and good must be made at this last moment.